|
|
Before The Crowd Arrives
A Wine Spectator Top 20 Sure Bet. Tenuta Nuova 2021: Its Highest Score Ever, 98.
Earlier this week we called Caparzo’s 2021 Brunello a Top 20 contender, and Wine Spectator named it No. 4. We did the same with Casanova di Neri. Wine Spectator publishes its full Top 100 on Monday; the 2021 Tenuta Nuova has 98 from Wine Spectator, 100 from Jeb Dunnuck and 98 from Falstaff and James Suckling. $159.99 a bottle.
• In Stock Now · The Last Cases We Secured Before Monday’s Top 100
|
|
Est. 1971 · Family Owned & Farmed · Wine Spectator Top 100 × 5 · Wine Of The Year 2006
|
|
Why Our Prediction Matters
“A Top 20 Contender.” Caparzo Landed At #4.
Earlier this week, we sent you an email explaining why Caparzo’s 2021 Brunello belonged in the Top 100, and likely the Top 20. Wine Spectator named it the No. 4 wine of 2026. Before that announcement, we moved to secure the very last cases available, so you wouldn’t have to compete with the sudden surge in demand.
We did the same with Casanova di Neri. Wine Spectator publishes the rest of its Top 100 on Monday, and before that announcement we moved to secure the very last cases of the 2021 Tenuta Nuova. You don’t need to chase this bottle, or watch prices climb once the spotlight hits.
|
|
A Personal Note
Dear Artisans,
Bruce Sanderson gave the Casanova di Neri 2021 Tenuta Nuova 98 points, Wine Spectator’s highest score ever for Tenuta Nuova. Every past Tenuta Nuova on Wine Spectator’s Top 100 earned between 94 and 97 points, and one of them, the 2001, was the 2006 Wine of the Year. Jeb Dunnuck went to 100: “It’s a gorgeous Tenuta Nuova that has everything working in harmony.”
Why We Saw It Coming
Every November, Wine Spectator ranks its Top 100 Wines of the year. It revealed the Top 10 this week, a wine or two a day, and the remaining 90 come out on Monday, November 16.
We did not just go on instinct. Expertise is mostly paying attention when others aren’t. We studied every Wine Spectator Top 100 list from 1988 to 2025, all 3,800 wines, and scored this year’s 90-point wines against them. The 2021 Tenuta Nuova came out among our 30 likeliest picks: 98 points from Bruce Sanderson, a real production of 4,900 cases, and a price that is modest for the score: Wine Spectator lists it at $135. Ours is $159.99.
A ranking doesn’t make a wine taste better, of course. It simply confirms what the glass already told us.
Casanova’s Top 100 Record
Casanova di Neri has been here before, five times since 1988, with the Tenuta Nuova 2001 named Wine of the Year:
| List |
Rank |
Wine |
Score |
Price |
| 2026 |
Top 20? |
Tenuta Nuova 2021 Our pick · full list Mon 11/16
|
98 |
$135 |
| 2017 |
#4 |
Brunello 2012 |
95 |
$65 |
| 2011 |
#56 |
Tenuta Nuova 2006 |
95 |
$80 |
| 2006 |
#1 |
Tenuta Nuova 2001 |
97 |
$70 |
| 2002 |
#24 |
Tenuta Nuova 1997 |
95 |
$65 |
| 2000 |
#51 |
Tenuta Nuova 1995 |
94 |
$49 |
Source: Wine Spectator Top 100 lists, 1988–2025. Price = Wine Spectator’s release price.
Tenuta Nuova has made the list four times, and the 2012 White Label once, at No. 4 in 2017. Two of the five were in the top five. Not one of them scored higher than 97. The 2021 has 98.
The Family Behind The Wines
Giovanni Neri founded the estate in 1971. Since his passing in 1991, his son Giacomo has managed the vineyards and the cellar himself, now assisted by his sons Giovanni and Gianlorenzo.
Christine, Joe and I have had the pleasure of sitting down with Giacomo, Giovanni, Gianlorenzo and Marianna Neri multiple times, stateside and in Montalcino, and they are a truly special, wonderful family: warm, exacting, and single-minded about giving the world great wine while elevating all of Montalcino with them.
A few snapshots from our visits with the Neris
Tenuta Nuova: The New Farm
Tenuta Nuova, meaning ‘New Farm,’ was a rocky ridge once owned by a shepherd, where nobody had planted Sangiovese before. The Neris planted its Le Cetine vineyard with vines cut from Cerretalto, their mother vineyard. Monica Larner: introduced in the early 1990s, Tenuta Nuova “marked a stylistic turning point for the estate, emphasizing precision, ripeness and site expression.” It ages 30 months in tonneaux.
James Tran
Artisan Wine & Spirits
|
|
Business As Usual
Perfection Is A Habit Here. The Record Speaks.
Beyond Wine Spectator’s list, a sampling of the perfect and near-perfect scores this house has earned.
| 2001 Cerretalto |
100 Points · Wine Spectator |
| 2015 Cerretalto |
100 Points · James Suckling |
| 2006 Tenuta Nuova |
100 Points · James Suckling |
| 2010 Tenuta Nuova |
100 Points · Robert Parker + 99 · Suckling |
| 2015 Tenuta Nuova |
99 Points · James Suckling |
|
|
Why This Matters
| • |
Wine Spectator 98. Its highest score ever for Tenuta Nuova; every past Tenuta Nuova on its Top 100 scored 94 to 97. |
|
| • |
Jeb Dunnuck 100. Plus Falstaff and James Suckling 98, Wine Advocate and Vinous 96. |
|
| • |
A Top 20 sure bet, by our count. Among the 30 likeliest picks in our study of 3,800 past Top 100 wines; the full list comes out Monday. |
|
| • |
Five Top 100s already. Including the 2006 Wine of the Year, the Tenuta Nuova 2001. |
|
|
|
The Six Wines At A Glance
Every score, every price. A full card for each wine follows.
| Wine · Ratings |
Top |
Price |
|
Tenuta Nuova 2021 · WS 98 WS 98 · FS 98 · JS 98 · WA 96 · VM 96 · Our Top 20 pick
|
100
Jeb Dunnuck
|
$185.00
$159.99
|
|
White Label 2021 JS 95 · DM 95 · JD 95 · VM 95 · WS 94 · WA 93
|
98+
Luca Gardini
|
$87.00
$79.99
|
|
Tenuta Nuova 2018 TWI 96 · JS 96 · WA 95 · VM 93 · WS 93 · Last bottle
|
96+
Jeb Dunnuck
|
$165.00
$134.97
|
|
Tenuta Nuova 2017 FS 96 · JS 94 · DM 93 · VM 93 · WS 93
|
96
Wine Advocate
|
$165.00
$139.99
|
|
Tenuta Nuova 2016 JS 99 · WA 97+ · DM 97 · VM 96 · JD 96 · WS 95
|
100
Falstaff
|
$185.00
$159.97
|
|
Cerretalto 2019 JS 100 · DM 99 · WS 98 · VM 98 · WA 98 · Last 3 bottles
|
100
Falstaff
|
$500.00
$449.99
|
|
|
Wine No. 1 · Wine Spectator 98
2021 “Tenuta Nuova” Brunello di Montalcino.
Wine Spectator’s highest score ever for Tenuta Nuova. Jeb Dunnuck 100. Falstaff and James Suckling 98.
|
|
|
Wine Spectator 98Jeb Dunnuck 100Our Top 20 Pick
Casanova di Neri Brunello di Montalcino “Tenuta Nuova” 2021
Montalcino, Tuscany · 750 mL
100 Jeb Dunnuck |
98 Wine Spectator |
98 James Suckling |
96 Wine Advocate |
From Le Cetine in Montalcino’s south, the estate’s “New Farm,” from Wine Spectator’s 99-point vintage. Wine Advocate finds it “more lifted and punchy compared to recent past vintages.” Vinous: “a fascinating vintage for Tenuta Nuova that shows a humbling level of complexity.” Every review is below.
Jeb Dunnuck · Audrey Frick · 100 Points The 2021 Brunello Di Montalcino Tenuta Nuova pours a deep red hue and opens with an exceptionally layered bouquet of suede, cigar box, tobacco, black cherries, and plum. Full-bodied, it’s packed with youthful tension at this stage, but it has a seamless, weightless feel, with polished tannins, refreshing acidity, and a flinty mineral edge that keeps the finish lifted and long. It’s a gorgeous Tenuta Nuova that has everything working in harmony and will only improve with time in bottle. Drink 2026-2050. February 2026
|
Wine Spectator · Bruce Sanderson · 98 Points Though tightly wound, this red reveals a buried core of strawberry, cherry, iron and wild herbs. A harmonious version, with a linear profile wrapped in firm acidity and tannins. Best from 2029 through 2049. 4,900 cases made, 1,500 cases imported. June 2026
|
Falstaff · 98 Points Rich, intensely sparkling ruby. Compact and dense on the nose, aromas of blackberries, plums, lots of tobacco and undergrowth. Full-bodied in the attack and on the palate, with dark berry fruit also present, opens up with dense, very well-placed tannins, fine enamel, lingers for a long time, juicy finish. March 2026
|
James Suckling · 98 Points Dark berry, walnut, cedar, thyme and some caramel aromas that follow through to a medium to full body with firm tannins and a tight and racy mouthfeel. Citrus and cherries at the end. December 2025
|
Wine Advocate · Monica Larner · 96 Points The Casanova di Neri 2021 Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Nuova comes across as more lifted and punchy compared to recent past vintages, showing a brighter fruit profile and added energy… Introduced in the early 1990s, Tenuta Nuova marked a stylistic turning point for the estate, emphasizing precision, ripeness and site expression. The tannins are well managed and elegant, and the freshness arrives with well-judged intensity… Drinking Window: 2027-2048. January 2026
|
Vinous · Eric Guido · 96 Points Citrus-infused herbal tea, crushed raspberries, pine shavings and incense beguile as the 2021 Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Nuova blossoms in the glass. It is surprisingly juicy yet deep and complex, with tart wild berry saturation and nuances of ground clove that add cheek-pinching tension and a balancing tinge of zesty acidity. An array of edgy tannins frames the incredibly long finish… This is a fascinating vintage for Tenuta Nuova that shows a humbling level of complexity. Drinking Window: 2028-2046. November 2025
|
Elsewhere: $185.00 Our Price $159.99 / bottle
|
|
• In Stock Now · The Last Cases We Secured Before Monday’s Top 100
|
|
|
Wine No. 2 · The Introduction
2021 “White Label” Brunello di Montalcino.
Luca Gardini 98+. Four critics at 95. From Wine Spectator’s 99-point vintage.
|
|
|
The Estate’s First BrunelloLuca Gardini 98+Made Since 1978
Casanova di Neri Brunello di Montalcino “White Label” 2021
Montalcino, Tuscany · 750 mL
98+ Luca Gardini |
95 James Suckling |
The White Label is the estate’s first Brunello, made since 1978. It brings together the estate’s historic parcels in the cool district of Torrenieri and sees 42 months in large oak casks. The top three reviews are below; every score is on the tiles.
Luca Gardini · 98+ Points Long oak wood refinement for the label-symbol of the house project. Dogwood, yellowcurrant and tangerine in olfaction, puffs of chamomile and dehydrated thyme, then juniper. To the juicy and savoury sip, with memories of flowers and red fruits. November 2025
|
Decanter · Michaela Morris · 95 Points Not to diminish Casanova di Neri’s single-vineyard offerings, but in 2021, my money is on the white label. This bottling brings together the estate’s historic parcels in the cool district of Torrenieri… The tight and sinewy frame guards the fruit closely but allows gorgeous floral perfumes to slowly seep out. Fine, chalky tannins are long and tactile. Very zesty too. Drinking Window: 2028-2042. November 2025
|
Vinous · Eric Guido · 95 Points The 2021 Brunello di Montalcino is an understated beauty, mixing dusty rose and lavender with shavings of blood orange and black cherries. It is surprisingly juicy yet elegant and refined, as ripe wild berry fruits slowly drench the palate in primary concentration. Structured and dramatically long, the 2021 finishes spicy and intense with nuances of citrus, clove and licorice. The complexity here is off the charts and the energy is incredible. November 2025
|
Elsewhere: $87.00 Our Price $79.99 / bottle
|
$74.99 / bottle at 6+ Save $30 on six · applied automatically at checkout
|
|
|
Wine No. 3 · The Last Bottle
2018 “Tenuta Nuova” Brunello di Montalcino.
Jeb Dunnuck 96+. James Suckling and The Wine Independent 96. One bottle left.
|
|
|
Le Cetine VineyardJeb Dunnuck 96+Last Bottle
Casanova di Neri Brunello di Montalcino “Tenuta Nuova” 2018
Montalcino, Tuscany · 750 mL
96+ Jeb Dunnuck |
96 Wine Independent |
From the Le Cetine vineyard, planted with cuttings from Cerretalto, and aged in tonneaux for 30 months. Monica Larner: “Here’s a treat from Casanova di Neri.” We have the last bottle. The top three reviews are below; every score is on the tiles.
Jeb Dunnuck · 96+ Points There is more depth to the 2018 Brunello Di Montalcino Tenuta Nuova, with light smoky earth, black cherry, licorice, and black pepper. It is polished with fresh crunchy fruit yet retains a good amount of concentration, with notes of black raspberry, turned fresh soil, and graphite. Mouthwatering, with salinity, fresh acidity, and great length, it has fine tannins and warming spice on the finish. Drink 2024-2044. March 2023
|
James Suckling · 96 Points Elegant and perfumed nose of dried roses, violets, lemon zest, slate, cherries, aniseed and truffles. Very fine, tight and precise tannins. Medium to full body. I like the floral and saline undertones. So precise and fresh with a tight finish. Crushed stones at the end… already attractive to taste and drink. June 2022
|
Wine Advocate · Monica Larner · 95 Points Here’s a treat from Casanova di Neri. Aged in tonneaux for 30 months, the 2018 Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Nuova is fleshed out and rich with pretty layers of dark fruit, dried blackberry, spice and cured tobacco. There is a point of sour cherry in this vintage that folds into crushed flower, balsam herb, licorice and crushed stone. The bouquet is classic, but the Casanova di Neri magic touch comes through thanks to the wine’s balance and pretty intensity. March 2023
|
Elsewhere: $165.00 Our Price $134.97 / bottle
|
|
• Last Bottle Of Tenuta Nuova 2018 · Once Gone, Gone
|
|
|
Wine No. 4 · The Favorite
2017 “Tenuta Nuova” Brunello di Montalcino.
Monica Larner: “one of my all-time favorite Brunellos.” Wine Advocate and Falstaff 96.
|
|
|
Le Cetine VineyardWine Advocate 96Falstaff 96
Casanova di Neri Brunello di Montalcino “Tenuta Nuova” 2017
Montalcino, Tuscany · 750 mL
96 Wine Advocate |
96 Falstaff |
From the Le Cetine vineyard in Montalcino’s south, with a full southern exposure from east to west. Monica Larner calls it “one of my all-time favorite Brunellos.” The top three reviews are below; every score is on the tiles.
Wine Advocate · Monica Larner · 96 Points This is one of my all-time favorite Brunellos… there is something timeless and solid about this wine. It’s like a touchstone… Make no mistake, Giacomo Neri builds wines for pleasure and sensual impact… But it also shows floral elegance and sour cherry freshness that defies our expectations of the vintage. February 2022
|
Falstaff · 96 Points Rich, bright garnet red. Intense nose with notes of pomegranate, beetroot, then lots of plum and dark cherry. Hearty and gripping on the palate, dark berry fruit, then opens up with lots of dense tannins, firm drive on the finish. |
Vinous · Eric Guido · 93 Points It’s silky yet juicy, pliant and staining to the senses, offering violet and lavender tones balanced by cooling acids and hints of candied citrus. The 2017 really plays with the palate… Balsamic herbs, salted licorice… it goes on and on like a spice box menagerie. An elegant pleasure bomb. December 2021
|
Elsewhere: $165.00 Our Price $139.99 / bottle
|
$129.99 / bottle at 6+ Save $60 on six · applied automatically at checkout
|
|
|
Wine No. 5 · The Historic Vintage
2016 “Tenuta Nuova” Brunello di Montalcino.
Falstaff 100. James Suckling 99. From Wine Spectator’s other 99-point vintage, ten years on.
|
|
|
Falstaff 100James Suckling 99Ten Years Of Age
Casanova di Neri Brunello di Montalcino “Tenuta Nuova” 2016
Montalcino, Tuscany · 750 mL
100 Falstaff |
99 James Suckling |
Decanter notes the Tenuta Nuova vines were planted in 1989 and are now hitting their stride. Monica Larner: “This is one of my sweetheart wines from Montalcino.” The top three reviews are below; every score is on the tiles.
Falstaff · 100 Points Powerful, bright ruby. Impressive nose with rich notes of wild raspberry, ripe, tree-fresh plum, in addition some liquorice, exciting. Salty and juicy on the palate, shows a lot of red berry fruit, then opens with fine-meshed tannin, polished and exceedingly long. |
James Suckling · 99 Points Aromas of blackberries, cherries, violets and bark with mahogany… full-bodied and chewy with intense tannins that are layered and focused. The fruit is pure and purposeful, yet not over done. Wonderful strength and purity to this. Class is the word. November 2020
|
Wine Advocate · Monica Larner · 97+ Points This is one of my sweetheart wines from Montalcino. The Casanova di Neri 2016 Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Nuova offers a long list of aromas on an ever-shifting and fluid bouquet. You get bright cherry, rose potpourri, black truffle, caramel, butterscotch, sandalwood, road pavement and chalky mineral… The mouthfeel is creamy and long, and the wine shows terrific tannic integration. November 2020
|
Elsewhere: $185.00 Our Price $159.97 / bottle
|
|
|
Wine No. 6 · The Last 3 Bottles
2019 “Cerretalto” Brunello di Montalcino.
Falstaff and James Suckling 100. Decanter 99. Three more critics at 98.
|
|
|
Single Vineyard100 Points × 2Last 3 Bottles
Casanova di Neri Brunello di Montalcino “Cerretalto” 2019
Montalcino, Tuscany · 750 mL
100 Falstaff |
100 James Suckling |
98 Wine Spectator |
98 Vinous |
Decanter: “At the far eastern limits of the zone, Cerretalto is Casanova di Neri’s coolest site… always released a year after its stablemates in the vintages it is made.” Vinous: “The balance here is otherworldly.” Of the 12 bottles we were allocated, 3 remain. The top three reviews are below.
Falstaff · 100 Points Deep dark, rich ruby red colour. The nose shows enormous density, cigar box, pickled sour cherries… Enormously creamy on the palate, very full-bodied, savoury, with subtle hints of iron, tightly woven tannins, very salty at the back, powerful, enormous length, a monument. October 2025
|
James Suckling · 100 Points Wow. Seductive aromas of slate, violets and black cherries as well as some graphite and cedar. Full-bodied, this has incredible depth, intensity and purity, building on the palate with focused fruit and pronounced tannins. Goes on for minutes. A wine for the long run. Best of the vintage? Try after 2029. December 2024
|
Vinous · 98 Points The 2019 Brunello di Montalcino Cerretalto is a showstopper, with a bouquet that mixes hauntingly dark florals, black cherries, incense, exotic spices and sweet sage. It seduces the senses with silken textures and ripe wild berry fruit scents… It finishes structured and impossibly long as a primary concentration lingers, leaving a stain of blackberry and sour cherry, all framed by regal tannins. The balance here is otherworldly. The 2019 Cerretalto displays all of the best attributes of this radiant vintage. Spellbinding.
|
Elsewhere: $500.00 Our Price $449.99 / bottle
|
|
• Last 3 Bottles Of Cerretalto 2019 · Once Gone, Gone
|
|
|
The Bottom Line
A 98 from Wine Spectator, before the spotlight hits.
The 2021 Tenuta Nuova is $159.99, in stock now. Wine Spectator publishes the rest of its Top 100 on Monday; when attention shifts, scarcity sets in, and prices tend to follow. If you want a bottle, it’s waiting for you, no chasing required.
And the rest of the house is above: the 2021 White Label at $79.99, the last bottle of Tenuta Nuova 2018 at $134.97, the 2017 at $139.99, the Falstaff-100 2016 at $159.97, and the last 3 bottles of the double-100 Cerretalto 2019 at $449.99. Knowing this family, the next perfect score is already in barrel.
Cheers,
— James Tran
Artisan Wine & Spirits
|
|
• In Stock Now · The Last Cases We Secured Before Monday’s Top 100
|
|
|
|
Leave a comment