WS Top 100 Rutherford Cult Cab at 1/4th Price of its Peers

Originally sent to our list on April 6, 2026. Pricing and availability reflect that date — for current pricing and stock, see artisan.wine.

ARTISAN WINE

SULLIVAN VINEYARDS · RUTHERFORD · NAPA VALLEY · 2021

⚠ FINAL ALLOCATION · ONLY 26 BOTTLES REMAIN

94 Points. Rutherford's Finest.
From the Vintage of a Generation.
26 Bottles Left at Artisan.

Sullivan Vineyards sits on Galleron Road in the heart of Rutherford — Caymus across the way, Staglin down the road, Hall, Beaulieu, and Cakebread all around. Their Coeur de Vigne is rarely available outside the mailing list. We have 26 bottles. We don't expect them to last.

94

WINE SPECTATOR

#75 TOP 100 OF 2024

94

WINE ENTHUSIAST

92

JAMES SUCKLING

92

THE WINE INDEP.

Winery Price: $120.00

$89.97

PER BOTTLE · 25% OFF WINERY PRICE

ORDER NOW — $89.97

Only 26 Bottles · Artisan.Wine · Ships Nationwide

Sullivan Vineyards Coeur de Vigne

WHY THIS WINE IS EXTRAORDINARY

We've Had a Relationship with Sullivan for 15 Years.
It Doesn't Result in an Allocation Every Vintage.

Their tiny production is usually devoured by their mailing list. But when we do get a call, it ends up being one of the best California Cabernet deals going. And it ends up going fast. That's what we expect from the 26 bottles we have left of Sullivan's 2021 Coeur de Vigne.

Grown in the vintage of a generation and aged untouched in the Sullivan cellars, this is a velveteen stunner raised solely at the Sullivan estate. It's drinking in its prime right now — blossoming with dark fruit, leather and cigar tobacco, allspice and mocha. Wine Spectator ranked it #75 in their Top 100 of 2024. Wine Enthusiast gave it 94. Four critics. Zero disagreement.

We invite you to put it up against neighboring wines that go for two times the price. Once you do, you'll know why Sullivan causes a stir every time we offer it.

THE VINTAGE

2021: Napa's Greatest Vintage
in a Generation

After the devastating 2020 season — when wildfires forced many producers to forgo red wine entirely — 2021 arrived as an answer to prayer. Cool nights, steady sunshine, no heat spikes, and historic drought conditions produced small, intensely concentrated berries that critics now call a once-in-a-generation event.

James Suckling calls 2021 an "apex vintage" and a "redemption year" — urging collectors to commit now because of the small quantity available. Jeb Dunnuck declared it "truly exceptional." Vinous found the wines "aromatic, refined and wonderfully expressive." The Napa Valley Vintners' one-line summary: "The joy is back."

Sullivan was built for this vintage. Dry-farmed at the Rutherford Bench since the 1970s, their vines have never known irrigation. Drought isn't a crisis for these roots — it's what they were born for.

2021

ONCE-IN-A-GENERATION
NAPA VINTAGE

"Apex
Vintage"

JAMES SUCKLING'S
VERDICT

"The Joy
Is Back"

NAPA VALLEY
VINTNERS

SIX REASONS TO ACT NOW

Why These 26 Bottles Will Not Last

🏆

TOP 100 OF 2024

Wine Spectator ranked this #75 in their Top 100 of 2024. That designation alone moves bottles. We have 26.

📍

RUTHERFORD BENCH

Caymus, Staglin, Hall, Cakebread, Beaulieu — Sullivan sits among the most celebrated addresses in all of Napa Valley.

💰

25% OFF WINERY PRICE

Winery price is $120. Our allocation price is $89.97. Neighbors with comparable scores charge $150–$200+.

🍷

DRINKING IN ITS PRIME

Wine Enthusiast says best from 2028–2038. Wine Spectator says drink now through 2038. The window is wide open.

📋

MAILING LIST WINE

Sullivan's production is almost entirely spoken for by their list. We get an allocation only occasionally, after 15 years of partnership. This is it.

2021 WON'T REPEAT

Critics call 2021 a once-in-a-generation Napa vintage. When these 26 bottles are gone, this exact wine — this year — is gone forever.

THE INSIDER VERDICT — 15 YEARS IN THE MAKING

When Sullivan Calls with an Allocation,
We Pick Up on the First Ring.

We've had a relationship with Sullivan for 15 years. It doesn't result in an allocation every vintage — not even close. Their tiny production is usually devoured by their mailing list before we even have a conversation. But when we do get the call, it ends up being one of the best California Cabernet deals going. And it ends up going fast.

This is the kind of wine that Sullivan's stellar reputation is built on. A velveteen stunner raised solely at the Sullivan estate — blossoming right now with gorgeous aromas of dark fruit accented by leather and cigar tobacco, allspice and mocha. At just $89.97 per bottle, it's an estate-raised Bordeaux blend from one of Rutherford's originals. Put it up against neighboring wines that go for two times the price. Once you do, you'll know why Sullivan causes a stir every time we offer it.

James Tran, Artisan Wine

Sullivan sits just off Highway 29. With Caymus just across the way, Staglin down the road, and Hall, Beaulieu Vineyard, and Cakebread all around — this is the Rutherford Bench at its best, home to some of the Napa Valley's greatest Cabernet Sauvignons. And at $89.97, it's the most accessible address on the block.

THE RUTHERFORD BENCH — YOUR NEIGHBORS

Sullivan's Address Is One of Napa's Most Coveted.

Every wine on this block is world-class. Sullivan is the one available at a fraction of the price.

Caymus Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon

One of California's most iconic names — the Wagner family's flagship Napa Cabernet is rich, plush, and consistently rated 90+ points. Rutherford's most recognized ambassador to the world.

SHOP AT ARTISAN.WINE →

~$90–$100

Napa Valley

Staglin Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon

Staglin is among Rutherford's most celebrated estates — consistently 95+ points, with an extraordinary track record for structured, age-worthy Cabernet from some of the Bench's finest clay-loam soils.

SHOP AT ARTISAN.WINE →

~$200–$250

Rutherford

Cakebread Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon

A perennial Napa benchmark — the Cakebread Cabernet is one of the valley's most consistent, food-friendly expressions of the grape, built for elegance and longevity over sheer power.

SHOP AT ARTISAN.WINE →

~$90–$110

Rutherford

★ Sullivan Vineyards Coeur de Vigne 2021

WS 94 #75 Top 100, WE 94, JS 92 — from the same Rutherford Bench, the same address, the same once-in-a-generation 2021 vintage. This is the discovery. The mailing list wine you can actually get. For 25% less than winery price.

★ ORDER NOW — $89.97 →

94/94/92/92

$89.97

All of these are extraordinary Rutherford Bench Cabernets. All available at Artisan.Wine.
The Sullivan Coeur de Vigne delivers the same address at a fraction of the price.

THE RESTAURANT PERSPECTIVE

Rutherford Bench Cabernet at Restaurant Pricing

Wine Retail Est. Restaurant
Caymus Napa Cabernet ~$95 $240–$285
Staglin Family Cabernet ~$225 $560–$675
Cakebread Cabernet ~$100 $250–$300
★ Sullivan Coeur de Vigne at Artisan $89.97 Buy direct. Skip the markup.

15

YEARS ARTISAN
HAS KNOWN SULLIVAN

2,600

TOTAL CASES
MADE WORLDWIDE

26

BOTTLES REMAINING
AT ARTISAN

2038

DRINKING WINDOW
WS & WE CONSENSUS

THE ESTATE — RUTHERFORD'S ORIGINAL

André Tchelistcheff Said It Best: "It Takes Rutherford Dust to Grow Great Cabernet."

James Sullivan purchased his 26-acre property from the Galleron family — the estate sits on Galleron Road — partially on the advice of the legendary Russian-American viticulturist André Tchelistcheff, Napa's most influential winemaking mentor and the man who transformed Beaulieu Vineyard into a world-class estate. Tchelistcheff's faith in Rutherford dust was not metaphor. It was conviction, earned across decades of tasting its wines. Sullivan listened.

For 40 years, Sullivan helped establish Rutherford as one of Napa's brightest lights. In 2016, Juan Pablo Torres-Padilla acquired the historic property, raising its profile while building on Sullivan's legacy of quality, elegance, and depth. The estate sits just off Highway 29, with Caymus directly across the way — and the same Rutherford Bench soils underfoot.

What makes the Sullivan property singular is its geological diversity. The parcel contains fully half of the soil types found across the entire Napa Valley — an extraordinary concentration for a 26-acre estate. Different varieties planted in different soils. Different expressions of the same block. All blended into one wine.

THE WINE — COEUR DE VIGNE

A True Estate Bordeaux Blend. Every Vine on the Sullivan Property.

Coeur de Vigne — "Heart of the Vine" — is the purest expression of what Sullivan's 26 acres can produce. The blend draws on every variety grown on the estate: Cabernet Sauvignon dominates, with Merlot for mid-palate plushness, Cabernet Franc for aromatics and structure, and Petit Verdot for color and grip. It is a Bordeaux blend in the truest sense — each variety pulling its weight, none dominating, all in service of the wine.

The 2021 was aged in 60% new French oak — enough to provide structure and depth without overwhelming the fruit. Wine Spectator called it "very Rutherford" — that particular combination of cassis purity, savory iron, and cut that defines the appellation at its best. 26 bottles remain at Artisan. $89.97. That's it.

THE BLEND

80% Cabernet Sauvignon · 14% Merlot · 6% Petit Verdot. Estate-grown on the Rutherford Bench, Galleron Road, Napa Valley.

THE AGING

Aged in 60% new French oak. 2,600 cases produced. Drinking now through 2038 per Wine Spectator and Wine Enthusiast.

Sullivan Vineyards Coeur de Vigne 2021 bottle

ALSO FROM SULLIVAN — WHILE IT LASTS

100% Merlot Rosé. 100% Rutherford Grapes.
360 Cases Made. Unheard Of.

The Sullivan Rutherford Rosé 2023 is not a pink wine made from leftover juice. It is a deliberate, estate-grown statement — 100% Merlot, sourced entirely from Sullivan's Rutherford Bench vines, made with the same exacting intention the estate brings to its Bordeaux reds. Only 360 cases were produced. That number is not a typo.

A single-varietal Rutherford Merlot rosé with 360 cases of production is, in practical terms, a unicorn. This is the kind of wine that sells out before most people know it exists. Serious rosé from a serious Napa estate, at a price that makes it the most giftable bottle we have in the store right now.

Sullivan Vineyards Rutherford Rosé 2023

Elsewhere $65.00

$49.99

Per bottle · 360 cases made

ORDER NOW — $49.99

WHY THIS ROSÉ IS DIFFERENT

100% Merlot · 100% Rutherford estate grapes · 360 cases produced. This is the estate rosé from one of Napa's most storied Rutherford addresses — made from the same Merlot vines that go into the Coeur de Vigne. Drink it through summer. Gift it without hesitation. At $49.99, it's the most elegant bottle of pink wine on the Rutherford Bench.

PERFECT PAIRINGS

What to Serve with This Wine

A full-bodied Cabernet-dominant blend with plush tannins, cassis, and savory iron demands an equally confident table.

🥩

IDEAL PROTEIN

Bone-In Ribeye

Also: braised short ribs, rack of lamb, venison chop, duck confit, or oxtail ragù.

🧀

CHEESE PAIRING

Aged Beecher's Flagship

Also: aged Gouda, Manchego, Comté 24-month, or Grana Padano with truffle honey.

🌿

VEGAN PAIRING

Wild Mushroom Ragù

Over pappardelle or polenta. Also: lentil shepherd's pie, roasted eggplant, or truffle risotto.

CELLARING POTENTIAL

How Long Can You Age This Wine?

Four critics. Two dozen years of runway. One conclusion: this is built to last.

17+

YEARS OF
AGING POTENTIAL

Now–2038

WINE SPECTATOR
DRINKING WINDOW

2028–2038

WINE ENTHUSIAST
DRINKING WINDOW

Open a bottle now to enjoy the wine in its prime. Cellar the rest through 2038 as the tannins integrate and the fruit deepens into something extraordinary.

CRITICAL CONSENSUS — FOUR PUBLICATIONS. ONE CONCLUSION.

WS 94 · WE 94 · JS 92 · TWI 92. The Critics Agree: This Is Rutherford at Its Best.

94

★ #75 TOP 100 WINES OF 2024

"Ripe and structured but fresh in feel, with a lovely, pure beam of cassis driving through, supported by mouthwatering apple wood, savory and iron details along the way. This red offers cut and drive, with the fruit lingering the longest thanks to a light hand with the toast. Very Rutherford. Drink now through 2038. 2,600 cases made."

JM — WINE SPECTATOR

94

"Cassis and blueberries, dark chocolate and spiced cocoa are carried on a framework of durable tannins into a persistent finish. This wine will do well with decanting to help open up its flavors, or can be held in cellar for several more years. Drink 2028–2038."

ELAINE CHUKAN BROWN — WINE ENTHUSIAST · JULY 2024

92

"Ripe blackberries and blueberries with notes of chocolate, vanilla and wet stones. Medium- to full-bodied, polished and smooth, with fine tannins and a lingering finish. Drink or hold."

JAMES SUCKLING · MAY 2024

92

"The 2021 Coeur de Vigne Cabernet Sauvignon, with 14% Merlot and 6% Petit Verdot in the blend and aged in 60% new French oak, is deep garnet-purple in color. It swans out of the glass with showy scents of creme de cassis, wild blueberries, and Morello cherries followed by hints of violets, menthol, and crushed rocks. The full-bodied palate delivers beautifully ripe, plush tannins and compelling tension to frame the bright yet generous fruit, finishing long with great purity. 2,600 cases were made."

LPB — THE WINE INDEPENDENT · NOV 2023

TWO QUESTIONS SERIOUS COLLECTORS ASK

Q: How does this compare to the big Rutherford names at $150–$250?

Rutherford Bench soil is Rutherford Bench soil. The geological DNA that makes Caymus, Staglin, and Beaulieu famous runs under the Sullivan property too. Wine Spectator called the 2021 Coeur de Vigne "very Rutherford" — their shorthand for exactly that combination of cassis purity, iron minerality, and cut that defines the appellation's greatest Cabernets. At $89.97, you are not buying a discounted approximation of what your neighbors make. You are buying the same address, the same vintage, the same appellation — at a fraction of the price.

Q: Why can we get this when most people can't?

Fifteen years of relationship-building. Sullivan's production — just 2,600 cases worldwide — goes almost entirely to their mailing list. We have an occasional allocation because we've been partners for a decade and a half. This is not a wine you find on a shelf. It's a wine that finds you — if you're in the right place at the right time. Right now, you are.

⚠ ONLY 26 BOTTLES REMAINING AT ARTISAN

PURCHASE AT ARTISAN.WINE — $89.97

SULLIVAN VINEYARDS COEUR DE VIGNE 2021 · WS 94 · WE 94 · JS 92 · TWI 92

The Case for Acting Now

26 bottles. $89.97. Twenty-five percent off winery price. Rutherford Bench. Vintage of a generation. Mailing list wine you can actually get. This is the call we waited 15 years to make.

When these bottles are gone, the 2021 Coeur de Vigne is gone. We don't know when — or if — we'll see this allocation again.

Winery Price: $120.00

$89.97

25% OFF WINERY PRICE

● ONLY 26 BOTTLES REMAINING · 2,600 CASES MADE WORLDWIDE
PURCHASE NOW AT ARTISAN.WINE

Cheers,
— James Tran
Artisan Wine & Spirits · sales@artisan.wine · Text 650-880-3553 · Call 650-917-8080

ARTISAN WINE · ARTISAN.WINE
2495 Old Middlefield Way · Mountain View, CA 94043


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published